Have you ever tried using best deer attractants or baits when hunting? If not, then you might want to stick around and learn why you should use deer attracts. You probably have heard a lot already about why you should or should not use deer attractant. But irrespective of what you have heard there is no denying the benefits of deer baiting.
Studies have shown that hunters who use deer attractants harvest 2.4 deer per 100 days while those who do not have a success rate of 2.2 in the same time frame. Additionally, a whopping 92% of hunters believe in the success rate of deer baiting. Whether you are for or against, there is no denying the benefits of the best deer attractant.
Speaking of the best deer attractant on the market, below I have sampled a list of the best deer attractant reviews just for your sampling. Now you might be wondering how I came to the conclusion that these are the best deer attractants.
Well, I relied on user reviews, my own personal experiences as well as expert opinions. Thus, these attractants have been selected based on what different users had to say about them. This is important since it gives you an in-depth look at what each attractant has to offer.
Brief Comparison of Best Deer Attractant
|
Deer Attractant |
Editors Rating |
Image |
Check Price |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Tink’s #69 Doe-in-Rut Buck Lure |  | ||
|
Deer Attractant Scent and Lure from Nationwide scents |  | ||
|
Buck Nut Apple Cover Scent |  | ||
|
6-Pk. Evolved Habitats Deer co-Cain Black Magic |  | ||
|
Lucky Buck Mineral Supplement |  | ||
|
Whitetail Institute Imperial Forage Oats Plus |  | ||
|
Top Secret Deer Scents All Seasons Combo |  |
Things To Consider Before Buying Deer Attractant
Before hitting the store for deer attractant, there are things you need to consider first. These considerations will help you figure out, which is the best deer attractant scent to go for.
Season
There are three main seasons in deer hunting, rut, pre-rut, and post-rut. The pre-rut season is when deer are preparing for mating. The rut season is the mating season while the post-rut is after the mating season. The deer attractant you buy should be suited for the season you are hunting in.
For instance, in the rut season, male deer will be busy looking for mates. Therefore, the best deer urine attractant will be ideal.
On the other hand, in the pre-rut season deer will be looking for food to prepare for mating. Therefore, in such a season look for the best deer attractant to mix with corn.
The Hunting Area
Different regions have different vegetation. Therefore, when shopping for deer attractant, it is crucial you consider what deer eat in your area. The most significant mistake you can make is using an attractant that is found naturally in your area.
Find out which foods are not so common in your area. Deer that are seen in Southeastern states have access to sufficient forage year around. Therefore, in such states, you are better off using other kinds of attractants and not forage.
Type of Deer
There are two deer types roaming our forests, black-tailed and white-tailed. These two are attracted to different kinds of food. Thus, it is important to know, which type of deer you will be hunting. White-tailed deer prefer low elevation stream, farmlands, and populated areas. Black-tailed deer, on the other hand, prefer brushy logged lands and coniferous forests.
Brand
There are many different brands of deer attractants out there, each with its own brand. It is important to know which brands excel at making attracts. You can learn this by going through the reviews of users.
Best Deer Attractants : No Forage!
Tink’s #69 Doe-in-Rut Buck Lure
- Easy to use Squirt Top
- Quality controlled formula
- Formulated from 100% natural doe estrous urine
Last update on 2024-04-20 / Please note that Prices and Availability Are Subject To Change /Paid links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
I have always been a fan of hunting during the pre-rut and rut seasons. So when I stumbled upon Tink’s #69 Doe-in-Rut Buck lure, I purchased it without a second thought. Last year I took down a big buck with this lure.
One of the things I love about this lure is how strong it is. Using this lure, I have been able to attract big bucks in minutes, especially during the rut season. Also, its squeeze bottle makes it easy to use. Whenever I want to use the lure, I just squirt a little on branches.
Features
- cogs
- cogs
- cogs
Pros
- check
- check
- check
Cons
- exclamation-triangle
Verdict
This rut deer lure might seem a bit pricey especially if you are used to buying lures at $ 5 to $7. However, as anyone who has used this lure will attest, it is more than worth the additional ten plus dollars. It is for this reason that this attractant takes the title of the best deer attractant scent on this list.
Deer Attractant Scent and Lure from Nationwide scents
- Nationwide Scents
Last update on 2024-04-20 / Please note that Prices and Availability Are Subject To Change /Paid links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
Nationwide Scents is one of the best producers of deer attractants. One of the company’s best sellers is the deer attractant scent and lure. If you are new to deer baiting, this is one of the best attractants around.
Many of the user reviews I read had nothing but praise for this attractant. Additionally, the people who use this attractant that I consulted admitted that they rarely go hunting without it. Therefore, this deer attractant deserves a spot on my list.
Features
- cogs
- cogs
- cogs
Pros
- check
- check
- check
- check
Cons
- exclamation-triangle
- exclamation-triangle
Verdict
Nationwide Scents goes through a lot of trouble to bring us the pure and fresh deer scent and lure. Therefore, the rather hefty price tag slapped on this attractant is justified. This is especially when you consider that you are getting 8 ounces of pure and fresh deer urine.
Buck Nut Apple Cover Scent
- Acorn Cover Scent to Hide Human Odor
- Use as Attractant or Scent Killer
- Long lasting Odor Eliminator Cover Scent Attractants
Last update on 2024-04-20 / Please note that Prices and Availability Are Subject To Change /Paid links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
For less than $15 you can get your hands on a scent blocker and an attractant packed in one bottle in the form of the Buck Nut Apple Cover Scent. The latter is essentially a scent blocker that helps mask your scent.
However, it also doubles up as an attractant. How you ask? Well, this scent blocker from Buck Nut emits the sweet aroma of apples, which is irresistible to mature bucks. So, is it worth buying to use as an attractant? Based on my research, this cover scent is amazing at attracting mature bucks.
Features
- cogs
- cogs
Pros
- check
- check
- check
- check
- check
Cons
- exclamation-triangle
Verdict
You are probably still wondering whether this scent blocker is worth buying as an attractant. Well, considering that you are getting two products for the price of one, this product is a true bargain. And in my opinion, it is worth every penny you will spend on it.
6-Pk. Evolved Habitats Deer co-Cain Black Magic
When I first came across Evolved Habitats deer Co-Cain Black magic, I was curious to know the reason behind the interesting name. So of course, I had to try it and see for myself whether it was as good as marketed.
Unlike other attracts already reviewed, this is a food based attractant. And true to its name, deer seem to be attracted to it as cocaine addicts are attracted to the infamous drug. Which is probably why Evolved called this attractant deer co-cain.
Features
- cogs
- cogs
- cogs
Pros
- check
- check
- check
Cons
- exclamation-triangle
Verdict
The premium price tag of this attractant can be a turn off for some, but when you read its reviews, you get to understand why its priced so. The Evolved Habitats Deer Co-Cain Black magic is a premium attractant sure to attract a lot of bucks.
Lucky Buck Mineral Supplement
It’s not every time you hear people praise an attractant for having an aromatic smell. But this is the case with the Lucky Buck Mineral Supplement. The user reviews and hunters I consulted all said one thing, this attractant smells so sweet it’s tempting even to humans.
However, do not mistake it for a scent based attractant. As its name suggests, this mineral supplement contains essential minerals. This is one of the main reason why deer love it so much. Just like the aptly named Deer Co-Cain from Evolved this mineral supplement has been likened to cocaine by those who use it. Some of the reviews went so far as to label it as the best deer attractant for trail cam.
Features
- cogs
- cogs
- cogs
Pros
- check
- check
- check
Cons
- exclamation-triangle
Verdict
There are very many deer attractants out there; however, not many encourage healthy eating among deer. This attractant from Lucky Buck is one of the few that does. Since it does not have molasses deer can only eat so much of this stuff. This means that they do not overeat. Also, it is reasonably priced considering you get enough attractant for year-round use.
Whitetail Institute Imperial Forage Oats Plus
Deer love oats, if you did not know, now you know. That being said an oat-based attractant is sure to do wonders. And that is what the Whitetail Institute Imperial Forage Oats Plus does. Ideal for winter, this attractant attracts deer.
And despite the fact that it requires planting, the results justify the hard work that goes into it. This forage is one of the best things to bait deer with during the winter season.
Features
- cogs
- cogs
- cogs
Pros
- check
- check
- check
- check
Cons
- exclamation-triangle
Verdict
The price of this attractant notwithstanding, there is a lot of advantages you get from using it. So, if you have a farmland you want to plant to lure deer, this forage will make a great attractant. Overall, this makes for the best homemade deer attractant on this list.
Top Secret Deer Scents All Seasons Combo
There are not many deer attractants that can be used in all seasons effectively. The Top-Secret Deer Scents All Seasons Combo is among the few. You can use this attractant during the rut, pre-rut and post-rut seasons.
Furthermore, this attractant works efficiently and is friendly to humans, thanks to it being ammonia free. When you buy this combo, you get three bottles of different scent based attractants. While this attractant does not occupy the position of the best deer urine attractant, it is worth a try.
Features
- cogs
- cogs
- cogs
- cogs
Pros
- check
- check
- check
Cons
- exclamation-triangle
Verdict
The Top Secret attractant combo is highly effective all year round. Therefore, if you want the best deer attractant for early season, this combo has it for you. On the other hand, if you want an extract to use during the rut season, this combo has you covered. Thus, while it is not the cheapest extractant out there, it is well worth the money.
Conclusion
When you go shopping for deer attractants, you will be bombarded by a wide assortment of brands. From those that claim to have the best deer scents and lures to those with the title of the best deer attractant block. However, it is wise to factor in all the things I have discussed above. This way you will be able to avoid making the mistake of settling on the wrong attractant to suit your hunting needs. In conclusion, when searching for the best deer attractant, there is a lot you will have to consider.
About The Author:
Lake Streeter, A Gun enthusiast, and loves to hunt in the middle of the wood. Always check the latest hunting gears out in the market and try to share his honest opinion with the audience in Hunting Nook.